As women learn about the proven health risks of conventional hormone therapy drugs, many are looking for natural alternatives, such as herbs and dietary supplements, to address menopausal symptoms like hot flashes.
One alternative therapy — products known as “natural hormones,” or “bio-identical hormones” — has attracted substantial new interest now that conventional hormone therapy products’ health risks have been made clear. This interest has been driven, in large part, by unsubstantiated claims promoted by companies and pharmacies that make and distribute these products, that “natural hormones” are safer than conventional hormone therapy drugs.
It is very important for women to know that these products are not necessarily safe just because they are “natural.” And, just because they’re prescribed by a doctor and sold in a pharmacy, it doesn’t mean they’re effective, either. The same questions we ask about menopause hormone therapy drugs’ safety and effectiveness need to be asked and answered for alternative therapies, too.
Natural hormones are powerful chemicals
Just like hormones synthesized in a lab, hormones made from natural substances are powerful chemicals that affect many parts of the body. The natural hormones most commonly recommended for women going through the menopausal transition are:
- Estriol: Estriol is a weak estrogen that is produced during pregnancy. High doses of estriol relieve hot flashes and other menopausal symptoms.1 It may also be beneficial in maintaining bone mineral density.2 Estriol is promoted as an estrogen that does not cause cancer; some proponents even claim that it prevents breast cancer. There is no reasonable scientific evidence that estriol has anti-cancer effects or is any safer than other estrogens, however.3 Additionally, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not approved any drug containing estriol, thus its safety and effectiveness are still unknown.4 Estriol is included in the tri-estrogen (or “Tri-Est”) mixture, which contains estrone, estradiol, and estriol. It is prescribed by health care providers and sold at special pharmacies (called compounding pharmacies), which mix the hormone into pills or topical creams.
- Progesterone: Progesterone is a hormone involved in menstruation and pregnancy. Its proponents claim that it prevents hot flashes, osteoporosis, and even breast cancer. The only claim previously supported by evidence was that progesterone helped reduce hot flashes. A recent study has yielded different results about progesterone’s impact on hot flashes, however, calling this claim into question.5 And, there is no credible evidence that progesterone improves bone density or prevents cancer.3 Progesterone proponents say it has different effects than synthetic progestins and is safe, but this is unproven. Estrogen-plus-progestin has been shown to increase the risk of breast cancer, as well as increase the number of deaths from breast and lung cancers. Estrogen alone does not have these effects.6,7,8 Topical progesterone creams area available over-the-counter in creams and under-the-tongue formats.
- DHEA: Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) is a hormone involved in regulating sex steroids, neurosteroids, and other bodily functions. Its use is promoted to prevent aging, cancer, and cardiovascular disease, as well as to relieve vaginal dryness and increase bone mineral density. Despite animal evidence to support these claims, current studies on post-menopausal women are largely inconclusive.9 DHEA may help reduce the vaginal thinning that occurs after menopause,10 and may maintain or even increase bone mineral density.11,12 Yet, some research indicates that taking DHEA may actually increase women’s risks for cancer.1,12 In women, DHEA can cause acne and increase facial and body hair. DHEA is available over-the-counter.
- Melatonin: Melatonin is a hormone that regulates the wake-sleep cycle and has been shown to help improve sleep.13 Some scientists think that nightly surges in melatonin may reduce the risk of breast cancer, but this has not been proven.14 There is no evidence that melatonin slows down aging, a promotional claim that is made to promote its use by menopausal women. There is also no information available about the long-term effects of taking melatonin on a nightly basis.15 Melatonin is available over-the-counter.
Making an informed choice for an alternative
A large industry produces and sells these alternative health care products, in much the same way that pharmaceutical companies promote the drugs they make. Alternative health care practitioners are subject to influence by these companies, just as conventional doctors are influenced by drug companies.
Regardless of whether they are recommended by a doctor, a nurse practitioner, a naturopath, or the cashier at a health food store, women should be skeptical of products that claim to extend life, reverse aging, restore youth, or prevent disease without any adverse effects. In too many cases, these products not only don’t do what proponents claim but also have dangerous health effects.
The FDA takes action against unfounded claims, but is it enough?
The National Women’s Health Network (NWHN) has long urged the FDA to exercise better oversight of alternative hormone products, petitioning the agency throughout the years 14 to do more to ensure that women get reliable and accurate information about these products.
In January 2008, the FDA took action against misleading marketing claims about natural hormones sold by compounding pharmacies, instructing these pharmacies that the safety and effectiveness claims they were making about bio-identical hormone products “are unsupported by medical evidence, and are considered false and misleading by the agency.”16
The FDA identified several specific misleading claims, including statements that natural hormones are “better” or “safer” than conventional hormone therapy and that natural hormone can treat or prevent Alzheimer’s disease, stroke, and cancer.
The FDA also said that the use of the term “bio-identical” implies “a benefit for the drug, for which there is no medical or scientific basis.”16 The agency also warned that selling products containing estriol is a violation of Federal law because the FDA has never approved this product.16
While the NWHN was encouraged by these actions, we remain concerned that they are insufficient to protect women’s health. We urge the FDA to do more, including to publish regulations about the appropriate labeling and advertising of pharmacy-compounded hormone therapy products.
We also urge the FDA to require that all labeling and advertisements for natural hormones provided to patients and health care professionals specifically note that:
- these products have not been approved by the FDA;
- because the products are compounded in pharmacies, they may not be subject to FDA standards for good manufacturing practices17; and that15
- the products have not been demonstrated to be safe or effective in clinical trials.
For more information on hormone therapy and alternative treatments, read the Network’s book The Truth About Hormone Replacement Therapy and our fact sheets on the topic: Menopause Hormone Therapy Overview, Menopause Hormone Therapy and Breast Cancer, Menopause Hormone Therapy and Cardiovascular Protection. Menopause Hormone Therapy and Heart Disease, Menopause Hormone Therapy and Ovarian Cancer, Menopause Hormone Therapy: Timing Doesn’t Matter, Herbs and Phytoestrogens, and Hot Flashes.
The National Women’s Health Network is committed to ensuring that women have access to accurate, balanced information about natural hormones at menopause. If you have a question you would like to ask NWHN, submit it on our weekly Q & A column “Since You Asked.” Stay informed by connecting with us on Facebook and Twitter.
1. Sites C, “Bioidentical hormones for menopausal therapy,” Women’s Health 2008; 2(4): 163-171.
2. Santen RJ, Allred DC, Ardoin SP et al., “Postmenopausal hormone therapy: An Endocrine Society scientific statement,” J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2010; 95(7):s1-s66.
3. Files JA, Ko MG, Pruthi S, “Bioidentical Hormone Therapy,” Mayo Clin Proc 2011; 86(7): 673-680.
4. U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Website, Bio-Identicals: Sorting Myths from Facts, Silver Spring, MD: FDA, 2008. Retrieved on July 15,2015 from: http://www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates/ucm049311.htm
5. Morrow PKH, Mattair DN, Hortobagyi GN, “Hot Flashes: A Review of Pathophysiology and Treatment Modalities,” Oncologist 2011; 16(11): 1658-1664.
6. Chlebowski RT, Anderson GL, “Menopausal hormone therapy and cancer: Changing clinical observations of target site specificity,” Steroids 2014; 90:53-59.
7. Chlebowski RT, Anderson GL, Gass M et al., “Estrogen plus progestin and breast cancer incidence and mortality in postmenopausal women,” JAMA 2010; 3014(15):1684-1692.
8. Cordina-Duverger E, Truong T, Anger A et al., “Risk of breast cancer by type of menopausal hormone therapy: A case-control study among post-menopausal women in France,” PLoS One 2013; 8(11): e78016.
9. Genazzani AR, Pluchino N, “DHEA therapy in postmenopausal women: the need to move forward beyond the lack of evidence,” Climacteric 2010; 13:314-316.
10. Panjari M, Davis SR, “Vaginal DHEA to treat menopause related atrophy: A review of the evidence,” Maturitas 2011; 70(1): 22-25.
11. Villareal DT, Holloszy JO, Kohrt WM, “Effects of DHEA replacement on bone mineral density and body composition in elderly women and men,” Clinical Endocrinology 2000; 53(5): 561-568.
12. MedlinePlus Website, DHEA, Bethesda, MD: U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2015, Retrieved on July 15, 2015 from: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/natural/331.html
13. MedlinePlus Website, Melatonin, Bethesda, MD: U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2015, Retrieved on July 15, 2015 from: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/natural/940.html#Effectiveness
14. Hill SM, Belancio VP, Dauchy RT et al., “Melatonin: an inhibitor of breast cancer,” Endocr Relat Cancer 2015, 22(3) R183-R204
15. Brzezinski A, “’Melatonin replacement therapy’ for postmenopausal women: Is it justified?,” Menopause 1998, 1(5):66-64.
16. U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Website, Compounded Menopausal Hormone Therapy, Silver Spring, MD: FDA, 2008. Retrieved on June 30, 2015 from: http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/2008/ucm116832.htm.
17. The FDA expresses these concerns on their website in addition to highlighting that certain bioidentical hormones have never been approved. However, this still has not stopped their manufacturing and promotion.